Don Mattingly’s Hall of Fame Case

April 16th, 2016
By Marneen Zahavi
0
400 views

Donnie Baseball: Hall of Famer?

Don Mattingly. Donnie Baseball. The Hit Man, if you prefer.

Six-time All-Star, three-time Silver Slugger, nine-time Gold Glove winner, batting champion, MVP, and New York Yankees captain — the accomplishments of Don Mattingly, inside Yankee Stadium and in ballparks across the league, grant him a kind of immortality. But is he a Hall of Famer?

Since his retirement following the 1995 MLB season, that question has proven far more contentious than anyone who watched him at the peak of his powers in the mid-1980s could possibly have guessed. He broke into the league in 1982, at the very beginning of that great dark era of Yankees baseball. As the long stretch of futility built, Mattingly kept the torch burning. He was a player who looked like the Yankees of yesterday, a player who might bring back the glory days. Mattingly soared to heights that few have ever reached, and if he’s ultimately a lesser god in that Yankees pantheon that includes Lou Gehrig, Babe Ruth, Joe DiMaggio, and Mickey Mantle, he’s still part of that pantheon nonetheless.

But is he a Hall of Famer?

The Don Mattingly Hall of Fame Case, By the Numbers

Go back to that list of awards he received and you’ll see it doesn’t describe a player who flashed bright and then burned out. Six All-Star appearances are indeed on the low end for a Hall of Famer, as is his total of 42.2 career WAR. But nine Gold Gloves? Only Keith Hernandez has more at first base — and Gold Glove history at the position makes clear how rare that company is. It should also be noted that his MVP and his batting title fell in different years, and he could probably make a case for being the best overall player in the game in at least one other year, too — 1986 comes to mind.

That tension between short-lived brilliance and career-long production sits at the heart of the Don Mattingly Hall of Fame debate. We can critique the use of awards as Hall of Fame barometers. Awards are necessarily qualitative rather than quantitative. They’re handed out by peers and writers, and they’re biased. Awards don’t represent a player’s “true” value the way advanced statistics claim to.

However, the Baseball Hall of Fame itself is a notoriously qualitative entity. It’s not the Sabermetric Hall of Fame, after all. What the awards do tell us is that the people who actually watched him play felt Don Mattingly was the best player in the American League at least once — he finished second in the MVP race the year after winning it — the best offensive first baseman at least three times, and the best defensive first baseman nine times.

But is he a Hall of Famer?

Peak, Decline, and Legacy

The Peak Years (1984–1989)

He led the league in doubles three times, breaking Babe Ruth’s franchise record in 1986 with 43 of them. From 1984 until 1989, he was a force of nature. Then his back failed him, after an initial injury in 1987, and the power in his sweet stroke began to falter. His batting average dipped, too — though, interestingly, his OBP never dipped nearly as much, thanks to a disciplined approach at the plate. His defense never abandoned him, but they don’t put you in Cooperstown on the merit of your defense alone. Unless you’re Ozzie Smith, of course.

Legacy Beyond the Numbers

His peak wasn’t long enough, and sure, he never won a World Series. His Yankees teams made the playoffs only once, in 1995 — his final year — and they didn’t get out of the ALDS. But as mentor to the next generation of stars who would lead the Yankees to four World Series titles in five years, his influence can’t be overstated. Looking back, of course his back would give out. You can’t pick up a franchise and carry it for ten years without feeling the weight. Even metaphorical burdens take their toll.

Even in those final years, when he was a shell of the player he’d been, he didn’t complain. He didn’t excuse his decline on the congenital back defect that had plagued him his whole life. Instead, he hit .300 and earned a pair of top-20 MVP finishes. Just a little more qualitative evidence that among the people who watched the most baseball, Donnie Baseball was still well worth watching.

So the answer is a resounding yes. In every way that matters, inside Cooperstown or outside it, the Don Mattingly Hall of Fame case is settled — he’s a Hall of Famer.